Should you bring a bucket or a thimble to the buying window for Disney shares?

Key Points

  • The House of Mouse is a fantastic company.
  • The stock looks expensive at first glance.
  • The lofty valuation metrics are based on a stretch of petite profits at the height of the coronavirus pandemic.

Entertainment giant Walt Disney (NYSE:DIS) is one of those stocks you should buy in almost any situation. As master investors Warren Buffett says, Its far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price. The House of Mouse is the walking, talking definition of a wonderful company.

That being said, the Oracle of Omaha would also advise you to take advantage of great buying windows for that rare class of wonderful companies. Opportunities come infrequently, Buffett says. When it rains gold, put out the bucket, not the thimble.

So is this a good time to grab Disney shares by the bucketful, or is it more of a thimble-sized investment opportunity today?

Lets have a look.

Market moves

2021 hasnt been kind to us Disney shareholders. Share prices have fallen 2% year-to-date, missing out on a 19% gain for the S&P 500 market barometer.


DIS data by YCharts

The stock has seen more than its fair share of volatility in recent months. Disneys shares are trading 52% above Novembers 52-week lows but also 12% below the all-time highs of early March. Prices have generally followed the broader markets daily trends, amplified by the business promise investors see in a post-coronavirus entertainment industry. Curiously, Disneys earnings reports have broken that connection all year long -- and not in a positive way, for the most part.

After the first-quarter report in February, Disney shares fell and started a long downward trajectory after the second-quarter update in May. Augusts third-quarter filing did spark a 5% jump the next day, but even that bounce was erased a couple of days later. All of this negativity rolled in even though Disney delivered three rock-solid reports. The company crushed Wall Streets earnings targets in all three periods and also exceeded analyst targets for the top line in February and August. Moreover, the Disney+ video-streaming service is growing like gangbusters, and theme parks are already back to positive operating profits.

Disneys unique properties

If you think that sounds like an incorrect market reaction to Disneys strong results, youre not alone.

As I said earlier, Walt Disney is a wonderful company. The business is built on a foundation of storytelling in several well-known worlds of rich characters. From fairy-tale Disney Princesses and diverse Pixar tales to Marvels superheroes and the Star Wars galaxy far, far away, Disney has a plethora of celebrated story worlds under its belt. And once Disney gets its four-fingered gloves on a fictional property, it has also mastered the art of monetizing this intellectual property.

For example, you can find Buzz Lightyear in theme park rides, themed hotel rooms and cruise ship cabins, video games, books, lunch boxes, and t-shirts. Multiply that effect by an ever-growing portfolio that currently stands at roughly 8,000 characters, and youll see why Im so impressed by Disneys money-making abilities.


Image source: Getty Images.

So, is it time to buy Disney today?

Some might say that Disney looks expensive right now. The stock is trading at lofty valuation ratios such as 283 times trailing earnings and 228 times free cash flows. Surely thats too rich, even for a media titan with nearly a hundred years of history and its eyes on an increasingly digital entertainment market.

But those trailing valuation calculations include some of the darkest days of the COVID-19 pandemic, where theme parks and movie theaters were closed and even Disneys TV network suffered low order volumes from nervous ad buyers. All of these terrible trends have started to reverse thanks to the ubiquitous availability of coronavirus vaccines in 2021, as shown in the rising revenues and recovering operating profits. Yet, at the same time, the stock has been hung out to dry, slowly losing value even though the underlying business is improving.

Therefore, I would warmly recommend buying Disney shares despite the sky-high price-to-earnings ratio. Those inflexible metrics are coming back to earth over time as Disney continues its recovery and tackles the media-streaming market like only a massive mouse in red shorts and yellow shoes can.

Theres a great, big, beautiful tomorrow for Disney and its shareholders. You can confidently fill your portfolio with Disney shares by the bucket.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium advisory service. We’re motley! Questioning an investing thesis -- even one of our own -- helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer.

Anders Bylund owns shares of Walt Disney. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Walt Disney. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.


Motley Fool Returns

Stock Advisor S&P 500

619% 141%

Join Stock Advisor

Discounted offers are only available to new members. Stock Advisor will renew at the then current list price. Stock Advisor list price is $199 per year.

Stock Advisor launched in February of 2002. Returns as of 09/01/2021.

Cumulative Growth of a $10,000 Investment in Stock Advisor Calculated by Time-Weighted Return Motley

Related Articles

Reach out

Find us at the office

Exel- Frazzitta street no. 61, 44925 Kingston, Norfolk Island

Give us a ring

Jovanny Boeding
+23 274 947 142
Mon - Fri, 10:00-21:00

Tell us about you